Joint Letter to the President
Joint Letter to the President from over 225 American Scientists

August 11, 2000

The Honorable William Clinton
President of the United States
The White House
Washington DC 20500

Dear Mr. President:

We are writing as scientists and natural resource professionals who are deeply concerned about the management of the 11.5 million acres of public lands that comprise the national forests of the Sierra Nevada and the Modoc Plateau. It is imperative that the Forest Service adopt a land management plan that takes into account the best scientific information available.

We encourage your administration to carefully consider the FSEEE-sponsored plan, submitted to the Forest Service by Forest Service Employees for Environmental Ethics (FSEEE). Their plan deserves your careful consideration for a number of reasons:

1) The FSEEE plan seeks to address pressing problems associated with unsustainable land management practices. Dramatic declines in populations of native fishes and amphibians, the disruption of natural disturbance regimes, and the loss of critical habitat for wildlife that inhabit old-growth forests, oak woodlands, and other terrestrial ecosystems, all indicate the need for significant new directions in land management. The Forest Service planning process now underway provides an outstanding opportunity to adopt a science-based plan to address these problems.

2) The FSEEE plan offers a landscape/ watershed-based management strategy that aims to restore the ecological integrity of entire watersheds, not just riparian areas or instream habitat. We encourage you to take steps to restore degraded watersheds and associated natural ecological processes and functions. We further encourage you to conduct watershed analyses as the basis for informed decision-making and take steps to reduce road densities, maintain adequate riparian buffers, and strengthen mitigation measures related to dams and other water developments.

3) The FSEEE plan proposes an extensive new system of designated national forest lands that would be managed to maintain, restore, and enhance ecological values and conserve biological diversity. We encourage you to include remaining late successional and old-growth forests, ecologically significant areas (as identified by the Sierra Nevada Ecosystem Project), roadless areas, and rare and declining plant communities in this system of public lands. The important role that these lands play in maintaining the biotic integrity of the Sierra Nevada must be preserved.

4) The FSEEE plan provides for a high level of landscape connectivity to ensure viable populations of wildlife that utilize the structural elements found in late successional and old-growth forests. We encourage you to maintain these key structural elements (large, old trees, large snags, large down wood, and hardwoods) in at least 50 percent of the general forest lands and to implement projects that will restore these structural elements throughout the Sierra Nevada and the Modoc Plateau. We also encourage you to coordinate with adjacent public and private landowners to promote a high level of landscape connectivity.

5) The FSEEE plan recognizes that natural disturbances, such as fire, play a vital role in maintaining the long-term health of forest and range ecosystems. Historic fire regimes in the Sierra Nevada and the Modoc Plateau have been significantly altered during the 20th century. We encourage you to adopt a regional approach that restores fire's natural role within ecosystems and across landscapes, reduces the risk of fire at the urban-wildland interface, and focuses fire suppression efforts in areas where substantial threat to human life and property may exist.

6) Finally, a scientifically sound monitoring program is needed for assessing the adequacy of the plan's conservation measures. The FSEEE plan proposes to track indicators of ecosystem health, population trends for rare and declining species, and other factors. This information can be used to evaluate and adjust land management activities for the purpose of restoring and maintaining the ecological integrity of the Sierra Nevada and the Modoc Plateau.

We believe the legacy of the past requires a significant departure from current management if we are to preserve and restore the rich natural heritage of the Sierra Nevada. We encourage you to emphasize a conservative approach to forest, watershed, and wildlife management. With so much at stake in the Sierra Nevada - and recognizing that we understand so little about how to maintain the ecological integrity of entire landscapes - we further believe that erring on the side of caution provides the best course of action.

In sum, we ask that you exercise decisive leadership to bring about a new era of ecosystem-based management in the Sierra Nevada and the Modoc Plateau. As a step in this direction, please direct the Forest Service to take a good, hard look at the recommendations offered in the FSEEE-sponsored plan.

Sincerely,

Note: Affiliations are provided for identification purposes only.
++ Denotes science team member, consultant, or contributor to the Sierra Nevada Ecosystem Project

CC: Al Gore, Vice President of the United States
Dan Glickman, Secretary of Agriculture
George Frampton, Director, Office of Environmental Policy, CEQ
Jim Lyons, Under Secretary of Agriculture
Michael Dombeck, Chief of the Forest Service
Jim Furnish, Deputy Chief, National Forest System
Brad Powell, Regional Forester, Pacific Southwest Region
Kent Connaughton, Project Manager, Sierra Nevada Framework

print this page...

The FSEEE
Sierra Nevada
Project
Introduction
Learn about this magnificent landscape and what needs to be done to protect it.

Restoring Our Forest Legacy: Blueprint for Sierra Nevada National Forests
The FSEEE Sponsored Plan for the Sierra Nevada; Submitted to the U.S. Forest Service, 1999

Scientists Comments
What 225 leading American scientists say about the FSEEE-sponsored plan for the Sierra Nevada

More Links



Sierra Nevada